Shocked Conservative Learns Obama Doesn’t Hate White People

Friday, July 20 2018

Shocked Conservative Learns Obama Doesn’t Hate White People

Barack Obama, speaking in Johannesburg, South Africa this week. Photo: Marco Longari/AFP/Getty Images This week, Barack Obama delivered a long and thoughtful defense of liberalism, pluralism, and democracy against strongman populism. The themes, which in nearly all respects tracked the ideas he promoted throughout his presidency, came in pointed contrast to the contemporaneous spectacle of his successor’s embrace of his favorite strongman.
The former president’s defense of liberalism included a defense of universalism, in contrast to a tendency in left-wing thought to essentialize all thought by its level of privilege. “Democracy demands that we’re able also to get inside the reality of people who are different than us so we can understand their point of view … ” he argued. “And you can’t do it if you insist that those who aren’t like you — because they’re white, or because they’re male — that somehow there’s no way they can understand what I’m feeling, that somehow they lack standing to speak on certain matters.”
The way for conservatives to acknowledge the appeal of Obama’s speech was to insist it somehow contrasted with his behavior as president. “Of course … this is the president who made Al Sharpton his ’ go-to man on race ’ and who said Latinos needed to ’ punish’ their ‘enemies, ’” writes National Review ’s Jim Geraghty. “It’s great that Obama realizes that identity politics can be corrosive to civil society and that they can Balkanize a once-thriving, relatively harmonious society. It just would have been good to hear this wisdom from a president instead of an ex-president.”
In fact, Obama said the same things many time during his presidency. (For examples, see here , here , here , and here .)
Geraghty’s examples hardly establish that Obama devoted his presidency to stoking hatred against white people. The Sharpton line links to a story depicting Obama’s administration using Sharpton as a mediator to stop violent protests in Ferguson . “Obama,” reports the story Geraghty links, “was ‘horrified’ by the images he was seeing on TV, Jarrett told Sharpton, and proceeded to pepper him with questions as she collected information for the president: How bad was the violence? Was it being fueled by outside groups — and could Sharpton do anything to talk them down? ”
The line about punishing enemies was a banal 2010 expression of hope that Latino activists would stop taking out their frustration on Democrats and instead exact a political price on the party that opposed immigration reform: “If Latinos sit out the election instead of saying, ‘We’re gonna punish our enemies, and we’re gonna reward our friends who stand with us on issues that are important to us’ — if they don’t see that kind of upsurge in voting in this election — then I think it’s going to be harder. And that’s why I think it’s so important that people focus on voting on November 2nd.” After a predictable outcry, Obama quickly apologized and said he wish he had said “opponents.” In any event, he was not calling for bloodshed.
Obama, of course weaved universalist themes into his appeal from the very outset, beginning with his 2004 Democratic Convention keynote speech, through his address about race in 2008, to his 2015 speech commemorating the 50th anniversary of the March on Selma, which placed the civil-rights struggle at the heart of the American story. The whole idea that Obama was elected twice, and left office with a 60 percent approval rating, by attacking the racial group that accounts for 70 percent of the electorate is absurd on its face. What possible logic would there be for Obama to attack the constituency that supplied the majority of his votes in both 2008 and 2012?
Conservatives spent the Obama era whipping themselves into a racialized hysteria, imagining the consensus-minded moderate president was waging an attack on their way of life. Trump won the party’s nomination because, at some elemental level, he grasped the fact that the impulse driving Republican voters had nothing to do with small government or policy at all, but an amorphous cultural backlash propelled by a belief that minorities were taking over.
Conservative intellectuals spent this period either stoking the backlash or denying it. Their most basic technique consisted of ignoring the conciliatory universalism of both Obama’s message and his agenda, while concocting out of thin air an imaginary Obama as a race-baiting radical.
Geraghty has imbibed the right’s caricature deeply. He quotes Obama saying, “It’s not just money that a job provides; it provides dignity and structure and a sense of place and a sense of purpose.” He snarkily replies, “Amen, Mr. President! How long have conservatives made this argument in various welfare-to-work proposals?”
You know who else made this argument? Barack Obama !
Giving poor people money so they could sit around and never work was what Republicans said was Obama’s policy, but it wasn’t actually Obama’s policy. So successfully did they persuade themselves of their own propaganda that, when coming face-to-face with the actual Obama now, they cannot recognize him.
Tags: top story politics barack obama donald trump liberalism Shocked Conservative Learns Obama Doesn’t Hate White People Most Viewed Stories Walking Dead ’s Andrew Lincoln Gets A Standing Ovation During His Final Comic-Con Farewell Why Trump Has Such a Soft Spot for Russia ‘I Couldn’t Stop Laughing. It’s So Ridiculous.’ A Surreal Week of Excuse-Making at the White House. The Bachelor ’s Corinne Olympios Was Duped by Sacha Baron Cohen for Who Is America? Segment Will Trump Be Meeting With His Counterpart — Or His Handler? Latest News russia investigation 8:25 p.m. Michael Cohen Questioning Trump’s Fitness for Office: Report With former personal fixers like these, who needs enemies?
politics 7:21 p.m. DNI Coats Swears He Meant No Disrespect to Trump He insists that his bewildered reaction to Trump’s White House invitation to Putin has been misunderstood.
politics 2:41 p.m. Trump Expected Pravda Questions at Putin Press Conference The president reportedly wanted to know why a journalist was allowed to ask him a difficult question about Russia’s election interference.
11:32 a.m. Trump Says Michael Cohen’s Taping of Conversation Was ‘Perhaps Illegal’ The president is gearing up for full-fledged battle with his former fixer.
9:00 a.m. Where Do ‘Centrist’ Democrats Turn in 2020? Joe Biden is the obvious favorite for those who aren’t crazy about the progressive drift of the party. But if he doesn’t run, then what?
Yesterday at 3:34 p.m. ‘I Couldn’t Stop Laughing’: A Surreal Week of Excuse-Making at the White House In the wake of Helsinki, the Trump administration is attempting to conjure an atmosphere of permanent uncertainty.
Yesterday at 3:16 p.m. A Global Heat Wave Has Set the Arctic Circle on Fire Temperature records are being broken all around the world this month and not even the Arctic is immune.
Yesterday at 3:07 p.m. GOP Awards Its 2020 Convention to the Only City That Sorta Kinda Wanted It More than likely, the 2020 RNC will be a global and local protest magnet.
Cohen Made Tape of Trump Talking Payment to Playboy Model and the FBI Has It After years as Donald Trump’s fixer, Michael Cohen is proving to be a problem.
Yesterday at 12:56 p.m. Anti-Abortion Activists Have No Doubts About Kavanaugh to SCOTUS If Brett Kavanaugh really hasn’t made up his mind about Roe v. Wade , why is the right-to-life movement fighting for his confirmation?
encounter Yesterday at 11:57 a.m. Talking Instagram, Trump, and Old New York With Michiko Kakutani For three decades, hers was the most influential voice in publishing. With the release of The Death of Truth, she now finds herself being reviewed. By Shawn McCreesh
Yesterday at 10:08 a.m. Trump Threatens to Slap Tariffs on Everything Imported From China So far the U.S. has tariffs on $34 billion of Chinese goods. Trump’s threatened to take that number up to $500 billion.
Yesterday at 10:00 a.m. McConnell to Dems: Delay Kavanaugh’s Confirmation at Your Own Peril McConnell is prepared to push confirmation hearings into October — and thus, keep vulnerable red-state Democrats off the campaign trail.
interesting times Yesterday at 9:17 a.m. Andrew Sullivan: Why Trump Has Such a Soft Spot for Russia The key thing to keep in mind is that his worldview is a lot like Putin’s. It’s the simplest explanation for everything we’re seeing. By Andrew Sullivan
Yesterday at 7:00 a.m. Conservative Shocked to Discover Obama Doesn’t Hate White People It slowly dawns on the right that the last president was not actually a race-baiting demagogue.
the sports section Yesterday at 5:52 a.m. NFL Anthem Protest Policy Put on Hold Under Agreement With Players’ Union The joint announcement came hours after a report that the Miami Dolphins might suspend protesters for four games sparked new outrage.
Yesterday at 4:40 a.m. Spy Chief Dan Coats Goes ‘Rogue’ by Not Validating Trump’s Russia Contradictions After standing by U.S. intelligence officials’ Russia assessments and chuckling about Putin’s White House invite, Coats might face the Trump’s wrath.
7/19/2018 at 10:28 p.m. The Progressive Hawaii Senator Reshaping the 2020 Race, Without Even Running Brian Schatz isn’t running for president — really — but his plan to yank Democratic colleagues to the left could define the party in 2020 and beyond. By Gabriel Debenedetti
7/19/2018 at 7:20 p.m. Trump Bashes Fed for Interest Rate Policy He Once Supported He really does not seem to understand that presidents are supposed to shut up about the independent Fed’s policies.
7/19/2018 at 5:22 p.m. The Double Down From Hell: Trump Invites Putin to D.C. for Second Meeting At a time when Trump needs to be focused on SCOTUS and the midterms, he may instead be entertaining his toxic twin Vladimir Putin.
Sign In to Comment